HomeWorld NewsUS appeals court overturns release of pro-Palestinian advocate Mahdawi, citing lack of...

US appeals court overturns release of pro-Palestinian advocate Mahdawi, citing lack of jurisdiction

A US appeals court on Tuesday overturned a 2025 ruling that ordered the Trump administration to release pro-Palestinian advocate Mohsen Mahdawi from immigration detention, finding that the lower court lacked jurisdiction to hear the case.

Mahdawi, 35, was one of several non-citizen students who were placed in deportation proceedings last year after taking part in demonstrations against Israel’s military campaign in Gaza. The arrests prompted court challenges that placed US President Donald Trump’s crackdown on immigration against the right to free speech as guaranteed by the First Amendment to the US Constitution.

Tuesday’s decision from a three-judge panel of the Manhattan-based 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals stopped short of backing the Trump administration’s push to deport non-citizens in the US lawfully on the basis that their presence in the country runs counter to US foreign policy – a practice that rights groups say infringes on free speech.

But taken together with another decision earlier this year in the case of pro-Palestinian advocate Mahmoud Khalil, the ruling could make it more difficult for non-citizens detained in immigration jails to quickly seek their release on the grounds of an alleged violation of their First Amendment rights.

Decision hinges on jurisdiction

Mahdawi, a West Bank-born Columbia University student, was arrested in April 2025 upon arriving for an interview for his US citizenship petition. Vermont-based US District Judge Geoffrey Crawford ordered him released on bond two weeks later, ruling that he enjoyed the same First Amendment free speech rights as US citizens.

Demonstrators hold placards that read ''Free Mohsen'' in reference to Mohsen Mahdawi, a Palestinian student at Columbia University, who was detained, as they gather at Foley Square in Manhattan, New York City, US, April 15, 2025.
Demonstrators hold placards that read ”Free Mohsen” in reference to Mohsen Mahdawi, a Palestinian student at Columbia University, who was detained, as they gather at Foley Square in Manhattan, New York City, US, April 15, 2025. (credit: REUTERS/JEENAH MOON)

In overturning that ruling, the 2nd Circuit panel said Crawford lacked jurisdiction over the case because it should have been resolved in immigration court first. The judges did not order Mahdawi’s re-arrest.

US immigration courts, which conduct deportation proceedings, are overseen by the Justice Department. District courts like Crawford’s, by contrast, weigh constitutional issues and are independent of the executive branch.

The panel included two judges appointed by Trump in his first term and a third appointed by former President George W. Bush.

Neither the Justice Department, which represents the federal government in court, nor the Department of Homeland Security, which handles immigration enforcement, immediately responded to requests for comment.

A spokesperson for the American Civil Liberties Union, which is representing Mahdawi, had no immediate comment.

Similar ruling in Khalil’s case

Earlier this year, the Philadelphia-based 3rd US Circuit Court of Appeals reached a similar conclusion in the case of Khalil, a Columbia University graduate who spent more than 100 days in immigration detention before his release on bond by a federal judge in New Jersey.

Khalil has asked the US Supreme Court to review the divided 3rd Circuit’s conclusion that his claims should have been heard through an appeal of a removal order from an immigration court.

Both Khalil and Mahdawi were authorized to be in the United States, and neither has been charged with a crime.


Source:

www.jpost.com

Advertisementspot_imgspot_img

Hot this week

France’s School Smartphone Ban Puts Classroom Conditions Under Scrutiny

France’s smartphone ban in schools has reopened debate over students, discipline and the condition of public education.

Alzheimer’s Warning Signs May Appear in the Brain Years Before Memory Loss

Johns Hopkins scientists found that two brain regions may shrink years before memory loss, offering clues to Alzheimer’s risk.

Medical Regulator Faces Scrutiny After Doctor Complaint Summaries Were Sent to Newspaper

The General Medical Council mistakenly sent The Times summaries of complaints alleging antisemitism and Islamophobia against doctors.

Microsoft Outage Disrupts NHS, Schools and Police Systems

A Microsoft outage has affected NHS, schools and police forces, while major airports and intelligence services remain unaffected.

Australia and England Meet at Adelaide Oval in Second ODI

England face Australia at Adelaide Oval in the second match of a three-game ODI series, with the scorecard central to the contest.

Voyager 1 Reaches a Light-Day From Earth, Deepening a Mission Beyond the Solar System

Voyager 1 is now one light-day from Earth, extending communications delays as the probe keeps studying interstellar space.

Medical Regulator Faces Scrutiny After Doctor Complaint Summaries Were Sent to Newspaper

The General Medical Council mistakenly sent The Times summaries of complaints alleging antisemitism and Islamophobia against doctors.

Anthropic’s $1.5 Trillion Target Raises the Stakes for AI on Wall Street

Anthropic, founded five years ago, is seeking a valuation of up to $1.5tn ahead of its planned stock market debut.

Google Declines UK Request to Remove Russell Brand Video From YouTube

Google declined a UK request to remove a YouTube video involving Russell Brand after his wife shared his claim of innocence.

Xi’s Diplomatic Opening Carries Influence, Visibility and Risk

Xi Jinping faces a delicate diplomatic test as engagement involving Putin and Trump brings visibility but also sensitive questions.

Bancroft’s Comments Put Cricket’s Sandpaper Scandal Back Under Scrutiny

Cameron Bancroft’s remarks have revived questions about Australia’s 2018 ball-tampering scandal in Cape Town.

Glastonbury 2027 Lines Up Harry Styles, Billie Eilish, Sam Fender and Cher

Harry Styles, Billie Eilish, Sam Fender and Cher are set for Glastonbury 2027, with Cher taking the Sunday legends slot.

Burnham Brings a High-Stakes Brexit Reset to Brussels

Andy Burnham’s Brussels summit with EU leaders opens a new phase in Britain’s post-Brexit debate, with trade and political ties in focus.
Advertisementspot_img

Related Articles