HomeScienceFederal Rule Overhaul Threatens Protections for Indigenous and Historic Sites

Federal Rule Overhaul Threatens Protections for Indigenous and Historic Sites

Federal preservation rules are facing a significant rewrite after the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation advanced a proposed rule in July that changes how Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act is implemented. The draft regulation would alter key definitions and procedures that govern federal review of projects that may affect properties listed in—or eligible for listing in—the National Register of Historic Places.

The current Section 106 framework requires federal agencies to identify historic and cultural properties, assess impacts, and consult with affected communities, including Tribal Nations, on a government-to-government basis where appropriate. Under the proposal, agencies would gain discretion over whether to notify the public or solicit comment and could determine when consultation is required. Agencies would prepare a Section 106 report and circulate it for comment, but they would no longer be obliged to respond to or incorporate consulting parties’ feedback before issuing final decisions.

The draft also narrows what qualifies as a “historic property,” requiring that a place include tangible human improvements and be geographically compact. This change would exclude many cultural landscapes, battlefields, and archaeological sites from review, with examples cited by preservation advocates including Gettysburg, Little Bighorn, Devil’s Tower, the Black Hills, petroglyphs at Chaco Canyon, and large natural sites such as the Grand Canyon. The rule further removes indirect and cumulative impacts and sensory elements—visual, atmospheric or audible effects—from the definition of an “Adverse Effect,” reducing the scope of what federal reviewers must consider when evaluating projects.

The proposal also changes mitigation and avoidance obligations by making mitigation contingent on whether measures are deemed “technically and economically feasible,” and it allows agencies to proceed when “other considerations outweigh” preservation concerns. Supporters argue the revisions would speed project reviews and provide predictability; critics say they would undercut protections built over decades and risk erasing Indigenous and archaeological heritage. The rule is currently under review at the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, and observers note the potential for an accelerated process that could limit public input as the changes advance.

Advertisementspot_imgspot_img

Hot this week

Ancient Skulls Reopen a Dark Question About Egypt’s First Kings

A new review of 46 ancient skulls finds fatal head injuries in 18, adding weight to theories of royal sacrifice in early Egypt.

Entertainment’s Quiet Reckoning Is Years in the Making

Brand, Walliams and MAFS controversies reflect a longer shift in entertainment, accountability and duty of care.

CERN Opens a Window on the Zeptoverse Without Breaking the Standard Model

CERN physicists have detected an exceptionally rare beauty-quark decay, probing zeptometer scales without yet finding new physics.

Leonid Meteor Shower Peaks Under Dark Skies Tonight

The Leonids peak overnight with up to 15 meteors per hour, fast bright streaks and favorable dark skies after moonset.

Beauty Advent Calendars Face a Value Test as Prices Climb

Beauty advent calendars can cost hundreds, raising questions over value, transparency and how shoppers should compare festive offers.

Voyager 1 Reaches a Light-Day From Earth, Deepening a Mission Beyond the Solar System

Voyager 1 is now one light-day from Earth, extending communications delays as the probe keeps studying interstellar space.

Medical Regulator Faces Scrutiny After Doctor Complaint Summaries Were Sent to Newspaper

The General Medical Council mistakenly sent The Times summaries of complaints alleging antisemitism and Islamophobia against doctors.

Anthropic’s $1.5 Trillion Target Raises the Stakes for AI on Wall Street

Anthropic, founded five years ago, is seeking a valuation of up to $1.5tn ahead of its planned stock market debut.

Google Declines UK Request to Remove Russell Brand Video From YouTube

Google declined a UK request to remove a YouTube video involving Russell Brand after his wife shared his claim of innocence.

Xi’s Diplomatic Opening Carries Influence, Visibility and Risk

Xi Jinping faces a delicate diplomatic test as engagement involving Putin and Trump brings visibility but also sensitive questions.

Bancroft’s Comments Put Cricket’s Sandpaper Scandal Back Under Scrutiny

Cameron Bancroft’s remarks have revived questions about Australia’s 2018 ball-tampering scandal in Cape Town.

Glastonbury 2027 Lines Up Harry Styles, Billie Eilish, Sam Fender and Cher

Harry Styles, Billie Eilish, Sam Fender and Cher are set for Glastonbury 2027, with Cher taking the Sunday legends slot.

Burnham Brings a High-Stakes Brexit Reset to Brussels

Andy Burnham’s Brussels summit with EU leaders opens a new phase in Britain’s post-Brexit debate, with trade and political ties in focus.
Advertisementspot_img

Related Articles