HomeOpinionWhy the question 'Can you be English and non‑white?' keeps coming back

Why the question ‘Can you be English and non‑white?’ keeps coming back

National identity debate has returned to the fore after Rishi Sunak used a column in the Times to warn against treating belonging as a matter of blood. Sunak, the UK’s first prime minister of colour and first Hindu, recounted an episode in which a podcaster dismissed him as not English because he was a “brown‑skinned Hindu” and described the experience as a “reverse Tebbit test”. In his piece he warned that suggesting someone is not English because they are not white puts the conversation on a “very slippery slope”.

Arguments over Englishness often draw on older cultural signposts. The so‑called Tebbit test — the idea that immigrants’ allegiance might be read from which cricket team they support — remains a touchstone in debates about integration and loyalty. Conservative figures including Jacob Rees‑Mogg have publicly pushed back against defining English identity solely in ethnic terms, yet tensions between civic and ethnic interpretations persist in political rhetoric.

The recurring question of whether non‑white people can be English has concrete social effects. It shapes media coverage of politicians and public figures from diverse backgrounds and affects how citizens perceive belonging. Sunak’s warning about a slippery slope highlights the danger that exclusionary definitions could normalise hierarchies of belonging and narrow the terms of public participation for minority communities.

As the country becomes more plural, discussion of Britishness and belonging is unlikely to fade. Public debate will continue to test whether national identity is anchored in ancestry or in shared civic values. The persistence of the question underlines the importance of informed, rights‑based discussion about identity, inclusion and the standards by which a modern democracy recognises who belongs.

Advertisementspot_imgspot_img

Hot this week

Schools Weigh David Walliams Books as Allegations Prompt Library Reviews

Schools, libraries and parents face choices over David Walliams books after allegations led some institutions to remove titles.

Portugal’s Housing Protests Hold Firm as Pressure Builds on Lisbon

Housing protests in Lisbon and Porto continue as Portugal faces growing anger over rents, landlord powers and renter protections.

Nvidia Rules Out Huang’s Return After Strong Quarterly Results

Nvidia says Jensen Huang will not be reinstated as the AI chipmaker reports strong quarterly earnings after his dramatic exit.

Russell Brand Proceedings Put Celebrity Power Under Scrutiny

Courtroom reflections on Russell Brand’s case highlight how fame, media access and public image shape accountability.

Zelensky Says Donbas-for-NATO Idea Has Surfaced in US Discussions

Zelensky says a proposal involving Donbas and NATO membership was raised by the US, which has not confirmed the remarks.

Voyager 1 Reaches a Light-Day From Earth, Deepening a Mission Beyond the Solar System

Voyager 1 is now one light-day from Earth, extending communications delays as the probe keeps studying interstellar space.

Medical Regulator Faces Scrutiny After Doctor Complaint Summaries Were Sent to Newspaper

The General Medical Council mistakenly sent The Times summaries of complaints alleging antisemitism and Islamophobia against doctors.

Anthropic’s $1.5 Trillion Target Raises the Stakes for AI on Wall Street

Anthropic, founded five years ago, is seeking a valuation of up to $1.5tn ahead of its planned stock market debut.

Google Declines UK Request to Remove Russell Brand Video From YouTube

Google declined a UK request to remove a YouTube video involving Russell Brand after his wife shared his claim of innocence.

Xi’s Diplomatic Opening Carries Influence, Visibility and Risk

Xi Jinping faces a delicate diplomatic test as engagement involving Putin and Trump brings visibility but also sensitive questions.

Bancroft’s Comments Put Cricket’s Sandpaper Scandal Back Under Scrutiny

Cameron Bancroft’s remarks have revived questions about Australia’s 2018 ball-tampering scandal in Cape Town.

Glastonbury 2027 Lines Up Harry Styles, Billie Eilish, Sam Fender and Cher

Harry Styles, Billie Eilish, Sam Fender and Cher are set for Glastonbury 2027, with Cher taking the Sunday legends slot.

Burnham Brings a High-Stakes Brexit Reset to Brussels

Andy Burnham’s Brussels summit with EU leaders opens a new phase in Britain’s post-Brexit debate, with trade and political ties in focus.
Advertisementspot_img

Related Articles